Peabody's Pizza Co.
Up Take & Bake Pizza Pastas Desserts Appetizers Peabody's Pizza Co. Peabody's Specials Build a Pizza Wraps and Subs Specialty Pizzas Build a Sub Beverages Party Subs & Platters Salads


Our Mission

Our food is made to order by pizza artisans using locally supplied ultra fresh ingredients. While many of our competitors use "pizza cheese" which is a blend of cheeses and fillers, we use 100% pure mozzarella and cheddar cheese shredded in-house. Their vegetables come pre-sliced, bagged, and soggy, but our produce is sliced or diced in our store guaranteeing you the freshest taste and texture possible. Peabody's dough is made fresh each morning, so you never get yesterday's pizza today.

Making a Peabody's pizza the old world way takes a little more time, a little more experience, and a little extra money, but we're certain you'll agree: the taste is bigger than what you're used to.

Company Profile

Marvin Goetsch is the Yoda of the pizza galaxy. He combines a flamboyant sense of "oomph" with the guidance of "the force" to deliver you products that are the envy of the dark side.

Ok... seriously: Marv has over 15 years of experience managing a pizzeria in Sheboygan, and has built a reputation of providing customers with the very best service available. Starting Peabody's Pizza Company allows him complete flexibility to tailor the products to what customers have been asking for, in addition to offering some other creative combinations that may become your new favorite.

We are open at 11AM daily, and in case you're wondering: "Peabody" was Marv's nickname during college.

Our products are made with ingredients from the following quality suppliers:




Sunday thru Thursday: 11am - 10pm
Friday and Saturday:  11am - 11pm

Contact Information

To place an order, please call:
Store location:
1123 North 8th Street
        Sheboygan, WI  53081